Cut, bulk or maintain?
Your body-fat percentage, not the calendar, decides whether to eat above, below or at maintenance, and how fast to gain or lose.
4 min read
Written & reviewed by Ricardo TapiaLast updated
Whether you should be eating above, below or at maintenance is decided by your body-fat percentage, not by the calendar or your mood. Body fat determines whether a surplus turns into muscle or into more fat, and whether a deficit costs you strength. Get the phase right and the diet almost writes itself.
Estimate where you are with the body-fat calculator, then read your number in the body-fat guide.
Men
| Body fat | Phase |
|---|---|
| 6–12% | Surplus: you have room to gain |
| 12–15% | Optimal band: maintain, or cut lightly (300–400 g/wk) |
| 15–20% | Deficit; you can still add muscle and strength |
| 20%+ | Deficit, no debate (400–500 g/wk), until back in the band |
The long-term rhythm is to bulk up to ~15%, cut back to ~12%, and repeat. Never bulk past 18–20%: beyond that the surplus mostly goes to fat.
Women
| Body fat | Phase |
|---|---|
| 10–12% | Surplus until ~20%, then switch to maintenance |
| 20–22% | Maintain and recompose |
| ~25% | Deficit, ~400 g per week |
| 30%+ | Deficit, up to 500 g per week |
Never bulk past 28–30%. A woman at ~20% who wants to get leaner cuts slowly, ~300 g per week.
Why a band, not a single number
The optimal band is where you are not hungry, recover well, sleep well and keep performing in the gym. Above it, extra fat worsens insulin sensitivity and makes the next kilo of fat easier to gain. Below it, recovery, training and sleep start to suffer. That is why the band has a floor as well as a ceiling, and why nobody should stay in a cut indefinitely.
How fast to gain
More food does not mean more muscle. The rate is capped by how much fat you are willing to gain, and that cap drops as you get more experienced.
| Level | Gain per month | At 80 kg |
|---|---|---|
| Beginner | 1–1.5% bodyweight | 0.8–1.2 kg |
| Intermediate | 0.5–1% | 0.4–0.8 kg |
| Advanced | 0.25–0.5% | 0.2–0.4 kg |
A true beginner can run faster in the first month or two, because much of that gain is glycogen and water filling muscles that just started training.
Check the tape before reacting to the scale. After two or three weeks, if the weight is climbing faster than planned, measure where you store fat first: the waist for men, thighs and glutes for women. If those sites have barely moved, keep the calories. If they grow while the lifts do not, you are above your ceiling: gain slower or switch to maintenance.
The opposite happens too. As you gain weight and muscle, the old surplus slowly becomes your new maintenance (adaptive thermogenesis). If the scale and the lifts both stall for a few weeks while the waist holds, add a little food.
How fast to lose
| Body fat | Ceiling per month | At 80 kg |
|---|---|---|
| Above 25% | 3–4% of bodyweight | 2.4–3.2 kg (~0.6–0.8 kg/wk) |
| 13–19% | 1–2% | 0.8–1.6 kg (~200–400 g/wk) |
These are upper limits, not targets. The leaner you are, the slower you must lose: the risk of losing muscle rises as fat drops. Around 400 g per week works for most people (300–350 g if you are light, ~500 g if you are heavy or have a lot to lose). Faster loss brings more hunger, worse sessions and sleep, and a hormonal cost; it also does not guarantee more fat lost, since much of a fast drop is glycogen and water.
Recomposition at maintenance
Gaining muscle and gaining weight are not the same thing. Inside the optimal band you do not need to pick a direction: eating at maintenance while training hard slowly swaps fat for muscle at the same bodyweight. A man at 75 kg and 15% can sit at 75 kg and 13% six months later; a woman can go from 22% to 19% the same way. If you are not hungry, recover well, sleep well and the lifts keep moving, there is no reason to raise calories.
These bands are coaching ranges, not diagnoses. Body-fat estimates carry an error of a few points, so use the same method every time and act on the trend.
Related
- BMR & TDEE explained: the maintenance number every phase starts from.
- Personalizing your diet: adjusting once you know the direction.
- Weight tracking: the target-weight calendar for the phase you picked.
- Diet quality: why a dirty bulk pushes you past the ceiling faster.
Sources & references
- Garthe I, Raastad T, Refsnes PE, Koivisto A, Sundgot-Borgen J. Effect of two different weight-loss rates on body composition and strength and power-related performance in elite athletes. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab. 2011;21(2):97-104.
- Iraki J, Fitschen P, Espinar S, Helms E. Nutrition recommendations for bodybuilders in the off-season: a narrative review. Sports (Basel). 2019;7(7):154.
- Barakat C, Pearson J, Escalante G, Campbell B, De Souza EO. Body recomposition: can trained individuals build muscle and lose fat at the same time? Strength Cond J. 2020;42(5):7-21.
Educational content only. Not medical advice; consult a professional for your situation.